French yields top 5% just before November, the weakest month for US yields
A political budget stand-off pushed French borrowing costs to a 24 year high, while the seasonal record for bond yields turns softer.
What happened
France's borrowing costs have climbed above 5% for the first time in 24 years as political concerns and the failure to agree a much-delayed budget spooked financial markets. The yield on the benchmark 10-year bond surpassed 5% on Wednesday as investors demanded a higher return for holding the country's debt.
Sources: The Guardian, Euronews. Details
Why it matters
France is the second largest economy in the eurozone, so a stress point in its bond market can spread to the euro and to other government bonds.
What history shows
The US 10-year yield has moved -1 bp on average in October since 1962.
EUR/USD has averaged -0.28% in October across 22 years.
Seasonal backdrop
November is the weakest month of the year for the US 10-year yield, with an average move of -7 bp and a rise in only 44% of years. The yield is -17 bp in October so far and +94 bp this year, so it is running well above the usual drift. EUR/USD is -1.01% this month, against an October average of -0.28%.
Scenarios
Possible paths and the signs that would point to each. No probabilities. Testable ones are graded on the scorecard.
Seasonal relief
French stress stays local and yields ease into November as they usually do.
- French budget agreement
- Falling bond volatility
Contagion
Selling in French bonds spreads to other euro area debt and pushes the euro lower.
- Wider spreads for Italy and Spain
- Weaker euro against the dollar
What to watch
- French budget vote
- Spreads of euro area government bonds over German Bunds
Sources and method (2)
- France's borrowing costs have climbed above 5% for the first time in 24 years as political concerns and the failure to agree a much-delayed budget spooked financial markets. The Guardian, Oct 21
- The yield on the French government's benchmark 10-year bond surpassed 5% on Wednesday as investors demanded a higher return for holding the country's debt. Euronews, Oct 21